Major Hospitals Still Not Complying with Price Transparency Rule

Nearly two-thirds of the largest hospitals in the US have yet to fully comply with the new price transparency rule, with most missing payer-specific charges.

Many of the largest hospitals in the country are still not complying with a new price transparency rule that went into effect on Jan. 1, 2021, according to a new analysis.

Nearly two-thirds of the 100 largest hospitals in the US by certified bed count did not meet all the requirements of the new rule, including posting payer-specific negotiated charges on their websites, by early February 2021, researchers from Hilltop Institute, a nonpartisan research organization at the University of Maryland, recently reported in the Health Affairs blog.

What’s more, just 22 percent of the hospitals in the analysis appeared to be fully compliant with the rule’s requirements, with some even exceeding the regulation in terms of the amount of pricing information they shared on public websites.

Researchers deemed hospitals compliant if their files were machine-readable and contained the gross charge, discount cash price, payer-specific negotiated charges, de-identified minimum and maximum charges, and descriptions of, and codes for, the items and services provided by hospitals—all requirements of the hospital price transparency rule.

For the payer-specific negotiated charges, hospitals also had to reveal both the name of the payer and plan to be compliant with the price transparency rule.

Most non-compliant hospitals (82 percent) either did not include the payer-specific negotiated rates with the name of payer and plan clearly associated with the charges or were in some other way non-compliant.

The remaining 18 percent of non-compliant hospitals did not post any files at all or the facilities provided links to searchable databases that were not downloadable.

This could leave a significant portion of major hospitals at risk of fines. CMS has stated that it will audit hospital websites to ensure compliance with the rule and it could penalize hospitals up to $300 a day for noncompliance.

CMS has said the hospital price transparency rule will lower healthcare costs by enabling consumers to shop around for high-quality, affordable care while also increasing competition among providers.

While there were several challenges of assessing compliance—uncertainty around whether hospitals included all items and services provided to patients and prices for all payers it works with, for example—the findings spell trouble for hospital price transparency effectiveness moving forward, researchers said.

“We are troubled by the finding that 65 of the nation’s 100 largest hospitals are clearly non-compliant with this regulation. These hospitals are industry leaders and may be setting the industrywide standard for (non)compliance; moreover, our assessment strategy was purposefully conservative, and our estimate of 65 percent non-compliance is almost certainly an underestimate,” they wrote in Health Affairs.

Hospital groups have been fighting to prevent price transparency rule compliance since HHS finalized the rule in 2019. The American Hospital Association (AHA) even led a lawsuit challenging the rule’s requirements, which was eventually thrown out by an appeals court.

Most recently though, hospitals have been calling on HHS to exercise enforcement discretion with respect to the price transparency rule because of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.

Hospital groups have said that enforcing the rule right now “will force overburdened hospitals to divert resources that hospitals desperately need to respond to the surge of COVID-19 cases.”

Previously, groups reported that aggregating all the pricing information and compiling it in a manner compliant with the rule’s requirements would be a major data project. HHS itself projected that the project would require 150 hours at an estimated cost of about $12,000, on average, in the first year.

However, researchers at Hilltop Institute said compliance should not be “insurmountable,” and the fact that 22 percent of hospitals in the analysis did comply suggests that “structural barriers are not preventing hospitals from posting their standard charges.”

“As the final rule notes at several points, hospitals already have all of this information in their electronic medical record and claims processing systems; while assembling and posting these required files entails some costs,” they explained. “Moreover, hospitals were already granted a one-year extension for this regulation. Given the 13 months between the finalization of the ruling (November 27, 2019) and the implementation date (January 1, 2021), hospitals should have had sufficient time to comply.”

Research has shown that price transparency in healthcare has led to lower prices for consumers. But industry leaders have criticized the hospital price transparency rule and, specifically, its requirement that hospitals publish payer-specific negotiated rates because they say it could actually increase prices by reducing competition in the market.


Call Today: 614.706.5206

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Popular posts from this blog

IMPORTANT UPDATE: Ohio Medicaid is upgrading its provider enrollment system

Effective August 1, 2022, ODM will not be accepting new provider enrollment applications or continue any in-progress enrollment applications through the MITS Provider Enrollment System. Details on the process for enrollment of new OhioRISE providers from August 1 to October 2022 will be communicated prior to August 1st. Effective October 1, 2022, all provider enrollment applications must be submitted using Ohio Medicaid’s new Provider Network Management (PNM) portal. After its implementation, the PNM portal will be the single point for providers to complete provider enrollment, centralized credentialing, and provider self-service. Provider Network Management Portal and Centralized Credentialing Beginning on October 1, 2022 the Provider Network Management (PNM) portal will accept Medicaid provider enrollments and carry out centralized credentialing functions. This transition will reduce administrative burden for providers and enable providers to focus on the more meaningful and importan...
Read more

CO Supreme Court: Hospital Cannot Enforce $229K Surprise Bill

The surprise bill stemmed from the hospital’s chargemaster rate, but the hospital did not provide this information to the patient before her surgery. The Colorado Supreme Court has ruled that a woman is not liable for her $229,000 surprise bill from a Centura Health hospital, as the hospital did not disclose the amount to her before the procedure. Lisa Melody French received spinal surgery at St. Anthony North Hospital in Westminster, Colorado, in 2014. The hospital initially estimated that the surgery would cost $57,601, with French responsible for paying $1,337 out-of-pocket. But the cost increased to $229,112 following the surgery. According to the court document, the new price tag reflected Centura’s full chargemaster rates for the surgery. Additionally, Centura determined that it had misread French’s insurance card and she was an out-of-network patient. French was left with the nearly $230,000 bill after her insurance paid $73,597 of the new charge, which was over $300,000. Fren...
Read more

Governor DeWine Announces Local Government Payments from National Opioid Settlement Begin

Image
    Ohio Governor Mike DeWine announced Friday that the first payments of funds to local governments from the OneOhio settlement with national opioid distributors have been made electronically. Local governments will determine how to use the payments, totaling more than $8.6 million, to best combat the opioid epidemic in their own communities. Following these initial payments, governments will continue receiving payments from the settlement over the next 18 years. In 2017, as Ohio Attorney General, Governor DeWine was one of the first in the nation to sue opioid makers and drug distributors for their role in flooding the market with massive amounts of highly addictive opioids. A complete list of payments made to eligible and participating political subdivisions may be found at https://nationalopioidsettlement.com/states/ohio/ . The list also indicates if the payment was made directly to the entity or, if less than $500, was redirected to the county. Questions about payments c...
Read more